Intro: After all the award buzz this movie was getting, before Christmas I decided to give it a go.
Film 2337: "Emilia Pérez" (2024), Jacques Audiard
Watched on: From my computer
Language: Spanish
Watched with: no one
Thoughts: It has been a while since I watched it and, funny enough, "Emilia Pérez" is now gaining a bad reputation after its multiple wins at the Golden Globes last Sunday.
For a (long) moment, it seemed like nothing could stop this movie: it won a Cannes for Best Actress and was getting nominated (and winning) everywhere, especially the performance of it cast, particularly Zoe Saldaña. But something has shifted after the Globes - the first televised award ceremony of the year, people have started watching either the movie on Netflix or the clips on TikTok and this is where things went south. Especially after "Emilia Pérez", a musical, has beaten "Wicked", another musical, in the movie of the year category.
So here's the thing: I watched this movie in Spanish, I read the lyrics of the songs and I paid attention, because I felt this movie was going to play a big part at the Oscar this year. So it had my full attention. And I can say two things: "Emilia Pérez" is not as bad as they're trying to paint it now, but it isn't the greatest movie ever made either (needless to say).
I applaud the idea of a musical about a man from the Mexican cartel transitioning and the portray of the struggle that comes with it, I think it's a different idea and the movie has it's moments. I particularly apprecciated and admired Zoe Saldaña's performance: a few minutes into the movie and I was ready to bet on her for the Supporting Actress Oscar win. (I really do think she has it in the bag.)
That said, yes, I did struggle a bit with this watch. The movie is very long (132 min) and none of the songs is a hit, really. There are a few interesting ones also visually speaking, but no song stuck with me and, on the contrary, I felt some of the performances from the supporting cast were actually really bad vocally. I understand that they didn't chose professional singers (Selena Gomez aside, and she does a decent enough job here to be fair - and yeah, her Spanish is bad, but what did you expect?), but the end result is sometimes jarring.
So, although I appreciated some bits of this movie, "Emilia Pérez" is definitely not my favourite movie of the year. Its cast does a great job and I was captured by Karla Sofía Gascón's performance (not in the lead category tho, I'd say more supporting, where Saldaña is really in the lead here, but anyway), some of the visuals and its themes (although some are critizing the stereotypical portraayl of Mexica culture) but other than Saldaña, I wouldn't give this movie any other award.
Cast: Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez, Adriana Paz, Mark Ivanir, Édgar Ramírez.
Box Office: $9.8 million
Worth a watch?: Definitely not a movie for everybody. It's a long musical in Spanish about violence, abuse, transitioning and many other heavy themes that could scare some people away. If you're interested in the controversy stemmed from the Golden Globes, then I would reccomend watching this movie and make an opinion for yourself, rather than just watching a few clips online out of context. Otherwise, if you don't care or you're not necessarily connecting with "Emilia Pérez'" themes, I would skip this watch.
Awards: Nominated to 10 Golden Globes, the movie won 4 awards for Best Motion Picture Musical or Comedy, Best Supporting Actress (Saldaña), Best Motion Picture Non-English Language, and Best Original Song (for "El Mal"). Currently, the movie is also nominated to 3 Screen Actors Guild Awards for Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture, Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role (Gascón) and Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role (Saldaña).
At Cannes 2024, the movie won for Best Actress (Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez, and Adriana Paz), the Jury Prize and the Soundtrack Award for Best Composer (Camille, Clément Ducol).
Key word: Children.
Trailer
#HollywoodCiak
Bengi
Watched on: From my computer
Language: Spanish
Watched with: no one
Thoughts: It has been a while since I watched it and, funny enough, "Emilia Pérez" is now gaining a bad reputation after its multiple wins at the Golden Globes last Sunday.
For a (long) moment, it seemed like nothing could stop this movie: it won a Cannes for Best Actress and was getting nominated (and winning) everywhere, especially the performance of it cast, particularly Zoe Saldaña. But something has shifted after the Globes - the first televised award ceremony of the year, people have started watching either the movie on Netflix or the clips on TikTok and this is where things went south. Especially after "Emilia Pérez", a musical, has beaten "Wicked", another musical, in the movie of the year category.
So here's the thing: I watched this movie in Spanish, I read the lyrics of the songs and I paid attention, because I felt this movie was going to play a big part at the Oscar this year. So it had my full attention. And I can say two things: "Emilia Pérez" is not as bad as they're trying to paint it now, but it isn't the greatest movie ever made either (needless to say).
I applaud the idea of a musical about a man from the Mexican cartel transitioning and the portray of the struggle that comes with it, I think it's a different idea and the movie has it's moments. I particularly apprecciated and admired Zoe Saldaña's performance: a few minutes into the movie and I was ready to bet on her for the Supporting Actress Oscar win. (I really do think she has it in the bag.)
That said, yes, I did struggle a bit with this watch. The movie is very long (132 min) and none of the songs is a hit, really. There are a few interesting ones also visually speaking, but no song stuck with me and, on the contrary, I felt some of the performances from the supporting cast were actually really bad vocally. I understand that they didn't chose professional singers (Selena Gomez aside, and she does a decent enough job here to be fair - and yeah, her Spanish is bad, but what did you expect?), but the end result is sometimes jarring.
So, although I appreciated some bits of this movie, "Emilia Pérez" is definitely not my favourite movie of the year. Its cast does a great job and I was captured by Karla Sofía Gascón's performance (not in the lead category tho, I'd say more supporting, where Saldaña is really in the lead here, but anyway), some of the visuals and its themes (although some are critizing the stereotypical portraayl of Mexica culture) but other than Saldaña, I wouldn't give this movie any other award.
Cast: Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez, Adriana Paz, Mark Ivanir, Édgar Ramírez.
Box Office: $9.8 million
Worth a watch?: Definitely not a movie for everybody. It's a long musical in Spanish about violence, abuse, transitioning and many other heavy themes that could scare some people away. If you're interested in the controversy stemmed from the Golden Globes, then I would reccomend watching this movie and make an opinion for yourself, rather than just watching a few clips online out of context. Otherwise, if you don't care or you're not necessarily connecting with "Emilia Pérez'" themes, I would skip this watch.
Awards: Nominated to 10 Golden Globes, the movie won 4 awards for Best Motion Picture Musical or Comedy, Best Supporting Actress (Saldaña), Best Motion Picture Non-English Language, and Best Original Song (for "El Mal"). Currently, the movie is also nominated to 3 Screen Actors Guild Awards for Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture, Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role (Gascón) and Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role (Saldaña).
At Cannes 2024, the movie won for Best Actress (Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez, and Adriana Paz), the Jury Prize and the Soundtrack Award for Best Composer (Camille, Clément Ducol).
Key word: Children.
Trailer
#HollywoodCiak
Bengi
